MINUTES
OF MEETING
NORTH
SPRINGS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT
The
regular meeting of the Board of Supervisors of the North Springs Improvement
District was held on
Present and constituting a quorum were:
Salvatore J. Mendolia President
Steve Mendelson Secretary
David L. Gray Supervisor
Also present were:
Ed Goscicki Interim Manager -
Pamela Rower
Dana Kaas
Bob Koncar
Dennis Lyles Attorney
Jane
Early Engineer
Nick Schooley Field Superintendent
FIRST ORDER OF BUSINESS Roll Call
Mr. Goscicki called the meeting to order and called the
roll.
SECOND
ORDER OF BUSINESS Approval
of the Minutes of the June 19, 2007 Meeting
Mr.
Goscicki stated each Board member received a copy of the minutes of the
There
not being any,
On MOTION by Mr. Mendelson seconded by Mr. Mendolia with all
in favor the minutes of the
THIRD
ORDER OF BUSINESS Public
Hearing to Consider Adoption of the General Fund, Heron Bay Mitigation,
Parkland Isles, Debt Service and Special Assessment Fund Budgets for Fiscal
Year 2008
Mr.
Goscicki stated this item will be discussed after Mr. Gray receives the Oath of
Office.
FOURTH
ORDER OF BUSINESS Consideration
of Resolution 2007-6 Rescheduling the Public Hearing to Adopt the Heron Bay Commons
Budget for Fiscal Year 2008
Mr.
Goscicki stated this item will be discussed after Mr. Gray receives the Oath of
Office.
FIFTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Staff Reports
A. Manager’s
Report
i. Consideration
of Cost
Share Agreement for Development and Implementation of BMP Program &
Amendment No. 1
Mr. Goscicki stated this is Amendment 1 to an existing
agreement the District has with the South Florida Water Management District. This agreement was put into place to
implement the best management practices for stormwater management. It extends the time frame by one year in
order to get these best management practices evaluated and reported.
On MOTION by Mr. Mendolia seconded by Mr. Mendelson with all
in favor the Cost Share Agreement for Development and Implementation of BMP
Program & Amendment No. 1 with the South Florida Water Management District
was approved.
ii. Ratification
of Authorization for Emergency Repairs to Pump Station No. 2
Mr.
Goscicki stated shortly after the last meeting, I was contacted by Mr. Nick
Schooley regarding problems with Pump Station No. 2. Apparently he picked up excessive vibrations
in the pump shaft and was concerned about pump failure. We brought in a pump repair company to give
us some diagnostics. Without repairs
being made, the concern was about the pump seizing up. This happened before the July 4th
weekend. As you know, we are in the
middle of our rainy season and we already had significant rainfall. We were concerned about waiting until the
next Board meeting to bring this before the Board and dealt with this as an
emergency and authorized the repair. We
have the plans showing what had to be done.
Mr. Schooley can explain this in more detail.
Mr.
Mendolia asked do we have any documentation to review and sign?
Mr.
Goscicki responded yes.
Mr.
Schooley stated these are lifetime pumps, which pump 50,000 gallons per
minute. We have three pumps at Station
2. We trained one of our staff to watch the
pumps and he noticed the shaft wobbling a great deal when we started the
engine. When I arrived at the station,
they already had them shut down and there was oil in the water. I called our pump maintenance company who
determined the seals were bad in two pumps.
They felt we could get through the summer but I did not want to take a
chance, knowing there was a problem. I
spoke to Mr. Goscicki and we decided to complete the repair work by Tuesday or
Wednesday, pull the other one out and complete both repairs two weeks from
today. These pumps are 14 years old and were
never serviced. We talked about servicing
them every 10 years as in the past; we only repaired them when there was a
problem. We never had a major problem. The repairs cost $8,000 for each pump for a
total of $16,000, unless we run into some major problems internally. There are two major bearings and if one is
bad, the cost will be $200 and $400 for the other bearing. They will not know how bad the bearings are
until they dismantle the pumps. If they
are not bad, they will re-install them. I
told them I wanted new ones. They told
me they can tell if they are good or not when they put them back in by pulling the
other out next Tuesday or Wednesday. He
guaranteed me a $500 discount because it saves them from using the crane.
Mr.
Goscicki asked what is the total cost?
Mr.
Schooley responded $16,000 for both pumps.
We made indentations in the prop, which has to be welded in for
balance. There was a great deal of
damage incurred to these pumps. The pump
company told me these metals were not normal metals for pumps. We just pulled one in February and it was in
better condition than these. He said
these are a different type of metal, which corrodes more and causes problems.
Mr.
Mendolia asked do we have a periodic maintenance program for once a year maintenance?
Mr.
Schooley responded they only need to be maintained once every ten years. I had pumps in for 15 years without any
problems. Of course we can install a new
pump and have problems tomorrow. If you
want to move in this direction, we will write a maintenance program for
maintenance of the pumps every ten years.
I suggest having a maintenance program for pump one in year seven, pump
two in year eight, pump three in year nine and pump four in year ten. This way all four pumps are maintained.
Mr.
Mendolia stated ten years sounds like a long time.
Mr.
Gray asked is there a manufacturers recommended period for maintenance?
Mr.
Schooley responded I think they recommend maintenance every seven to ten
years. I do not think it is a stated
recommendation.
Mr.
Gray asked are they only doing repairs to what was damaged or are we doing
long-term maintenance? Is there
something they should be doing while they have the pumps out?
Mr.
Schooley responded no. With the oil in
the water and wobbling of the shaft, they are replacing the seals as they hold
the oil in the pump. If the seals are
bad, the oil is going to leak in the water.
It was not a bad leak but there was a sheen on the water. What you have is a shaft, propeller, two or
three bearings and two or three seals.
When you maintain the bearings and seals every ten years, you are going
to have a new pump.
Mr.
Mendolia asked how many pumps do we have with the wrong type of metal?
Mr.
Schooley responded three at this pump station.
I assume they are all the same.
We can do this every seven to ten years at our discretion in the off
season when there are no hurricanes. I
will coordinate a program with Mr. Goscicki.
No matter who is in charge here, we will go this route.
Mr.
Mendelson stated you are saying, within this ten year period, each pump will be
serviced.
Mr.
Schooley stated correct.
Mr.
Mendelson asked what is the total lifespan of those pumps?
Mr.
Schooley responded I had pumps in the Sunshine WCD that were 30 years old. Today’s standards are not what they used to
be as far as metal and workmanship and they are not going to last like they
used to.
Mr.
Mendolia asked do you have any documentation we can review?
Mr.
Goscicki responded I will have to obtain the documentation. At this time, we are asking you to approve
the work authorization in an amount not to exceed $16,000 for emergency
repairs.
Mr.
Lyles asked is the not to exceed amount going to be sufficient? This is typically how the Board authorizes
something when they do not have the contract in front of them.
Mr.
Goscicki responded the price of the proposal was in the not to exceed amount of
$16,000.
Mr.
Schooley stated the cost is $8,000 per pump for the seals, re-conditioning, dismantling,
painting, cleaning and sandblasting.
This is standard work if the bearings are bad. They cannot give you a price because they do
not know what is needed until they dismantle the pumps. I never exceed what the Board verbally agrees
to.
Mr.
Lyles stated the question was whether $16,000 was enough.
Mr.
Schooley stated $16,000 may not be enough because there was damage to the pump
and we may have to do some welding.
Mr.
Goscicki stated a not to exceed amount of $20,000 may be more adequate.
On MOTION by Mr. Mendelson seconded by Mr. Mendolia with all
in favor staff was authorized to prepare a work authorization for the emergency
repairs to Pump Station No. 2 in an amount not to exceed $20,000.
Mr.
Gray stated I worked for a manufacturer who produced pumps like this for 18 years. I am a Mechanical Engineer and understand a
significant amount to explain the issue.
Mr.
Mendolia stated we do not need you to go into detail.
Mr.
Gray asked if they say the bearings are not bad and there is a life expectancy
for them and it will only cost $500 more to replace, is it worth replacing the
bearings if they are beyond their life expectancy?
Mr.
Schooley responded this is my thought but the pump company told me they can
visually tell if it does not help to put a new bearing in instead of spending
$500. I do not want to spend $500. If it does not look new, I do not want
it. However, if it looks new, let’s do
it.
Mr.
Gray stated most products have some life expectancy.
Mr.
Schooley stated if they tell me a new one is no better than this one, I
certainly am not spending another $500 to $600.
Organizational Matters
● Oath of Office for David L. Gray
Ms.
Robin Dvorshak being a Notary of the State of
A. Manager’s
Report (Continued)
Mr.
Goscicki stated I want to introduce Mr. Bob Koncar and Mr. Dana Kaas from Severn
Trent Services. Mr. Kaas oversees all of
our operations in
THIRD
ORDER OF BUSINESS Public
Hearing to Consider Adoption of the General Fund, Heron Bay Mitigation,
Parkland Isles, Debt Service and Special Assessment Fund Budgets for Fiscal
Year 2008
Mr.
Goscicki stated we provided to you under separate cover the proposed budgets,
which were reviewed with the Board at the last meeting. The only change was to the budget for Heron
Bay Commons. At the last meeting, the
Board directed us to develop multiple budgets and look at how to fund the
tennis court improvements. However,
since those multiple budgets resulted in an assessment increase, we have to do
a public notice by first class mail to all residents. This notice did not go out in time, which we
apologize for. Hence, there are no
members of the public here to discuss the budget. Obviously the public hearing notice was
published in the newspaper but the individual notifications did not go
out. All of the other budgets are
exactly the same as the ones we reviewed with the Board last month and reflect
no increases in assessments from the previous year. At this time, we want the Board to open the
public hearing to take comments from the audience or the Board. If there are no comments, we can close the
public hearing to consider approval of those budgets. At our next meeting on August 9th,
we will consider the Heron Bay Commons Budget as a separate item. With the Board’s concurrence, the public
hearing is now open. Are there any
comments from the public?
Mr.
Lyles responded for the record, there should be a quick review on the budget
numbers and the purpose of the increases, if any.
Mr.
Goscicki stated there are five budgets; General Fund Budget, Heron Bay
Mitigation Budget, Parkland Isles Budget, Debt Service and Special Assessment
Fund Budgets. The current assessment of
the General Fund Budget is $74.50 per unit.
We propose keeping this amount the same.
The budget provides the general administration of the District and field
operations associated with canal maintenance.
The total amount of this budget is $1,131,339 for revenues and
expenditures with no increase in assessments per the Board’s direction. We moved some dollars around and are
comfortable with the level of funding in this budget as you have sufficient
reserve funds moving forward into next year.
We are comfortable this is a workable budget.
The
second budget is the Heron Bay Mitigation Budget, which is for the single
purpose of funding the mitigation operations within
The
Parkland Isles Budget deals with landscape maintenance operations and
irrigation plant replacement within Parkland Isles. There is also a small administration fee. The total amount of this budget is
$292,162. The assessment per unit is
significant because there are a small number of units. The current assessment is $499 per unit with
no increase in 2008.
The
Debt Service Fund Budget deals with the debt service for the District. The assessment per unit remains the same as
the debt remains the same. The
amortization schedule is attached to the budget. The first series will be paid down in 2010
and the second series will be paid down in 2024.
The
Special Assessment Fund Budget consists of the Series 1997
Mr.
Mendolia asked is this resolution for all of the budgets?
Mr.
Lyles responded the resolution covers all of the budgets the manager just
outlined. They are listed in the title
and in the body of the resolution. This
resolution is being adopted pursuant to the public notice and public hearing
held today, unless there are any questions from the Board or the public.
On
MOTION by Mr. Mendelson seconded by Mr. Gray with all in favor Resolution
2007-5 Adopting the General Fund, Heron Bay Mitigation, Parkland Isles, Debt
Service and Special Assessment Fund Budgets for Fiscal Year 2008 was adopted.
FOURTH
ORDER OF BUSINESS Consideration
of Resolution 2007-6 Rescheduling the Public Hearing to Adopt the Heron Bay
Commons Budget for Fiscal Year 2008
Mr.
Goscicki stated we request the Board’s approval of Resolution 2007-6,
rescheduling the public hearing to adopt the Heron Bay Commons Budget for
fiscal year 2008 to
On
MOTION by Mr. Mendolia seconded by Mr. Mendelson with all in favor Resolution
2007-6 Rescheduling the Public Hearing to Adopt the Heron Bay Commons Budget
for Fiscal Year 2008 for
FIFTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Staff Reports
(Continued)
B. Attorney’s
Report
Mr.
Lyles stated as I reported to you at the last meeting, our legislation filed
with
You
may be aware of a dispute regarding median maintenance and responsibility with
the City of
Mr.
Mendolia stated I hope so because you know my feelings on this matter.
Mr.
Lyles stated we received our direction from the Board.
Mr.
Goscicki stated we will continue working with WCI and use their leverage to get
the adjacent HOA’s to take over the median maintenance in those areas.
Mr.
Mendolia stated I said all I have to say on this matter.
C. Engineer’s
Report
There
not being any, the next item followed.
SEVENTH
ORDER OF BUSINESS Supervisor’s
Requests and Audience Comments
There
not being any, the next item followed.
SIXTH
ORDER OF BUSINESS Approval
of Requisitions and Invoices
There
being no questions or comments,
On MOTION by Mr. Mendelson seconded by Mr. Mendolia with all
in favor the requisitions and check registers for the month of June for the
General Fund in the amount of $124,029.84, Heron Bay in the amount of $120,103.98,
Parkland Isles in the amount of $336.67, Heron Bay Mitigation in the amount of
$21,273.85 and the Water & Sewer Fund in the amount of $1,090,308.94 were
approved.
EIGHTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Adjournment
There
being no further business,
On MOTION by Mr. Mendelson seconded by Mr. Mendolia with all
in favor the meeting was adjourned.
Steve
Mendelson Salvatore
J. Mendolia
Secretary President